Status
On this page
Status
Topics
Status
On this page
Status
Topics
Let
be a trigonometric polynomial all of whose roots are real, such that . Then
Let
with and be a trigonometric polynomial all of whose roots are real, such that . Then
Source: erdosproblems.com/225
An accepted solution exists. The statement is true.
Proved, the site's label. The site credits two independent solutions, Kristiansen [Kr74], which it describes as the real-coefficient case, and Saff and Sheil-Small [SaSh74] for general complex coefficients. The claim pages Saff and Sheil-Small 1974, accepted on its refereed publication and the site's credit, and Kristiansen 1974, accepted on its refereed publication, record them. Kristiansen's theorem is the two-sided real form, a real trigonometric polynomial of degree with real roots, which implies the display for arbitrary complex coefficients; the site's description is narrower than his paper. Both routes prove the corrected Statement; this project's own review of the compiled chain is described under Review record below and awards no standing.
The site's display admits degenerate cases for which the bound fails. The constant () has no roots, maximum and integral . If roots are read as zeros of as an entire function of , fails the same way. The problem's sources state the conjecture with every root counted. Kristiansen states it for a trigonometric polynomial of degree with real coefficients and real roots (Proc. Amer. Math. Soc. 44 (1974), p. 49). Saff and Sheil-Small state it for one of degree with all zeros in real (their Conjecture 1). The corrected Statement follows them: and , so that is the actual degree of , and every one of the algebraic roots of , counting multiplicity, on the unit circle, of the form with real. The site's display does not state a root count; the full-root reading is the hypothesis used in the exact transfer below. The corrected Statement is proved, by Kristiansen [Kr74] (a two-sided real theorem, which the site describes as the real-coefficient case) and by Saff and Sheil-Small [SaSh74] in general (see Status). The site's wording fails at the degenerate cases above, and no other result about it is recorded.
Saff and Sheil-Small also prove an equivalent two-sided theorem. Their degree- trigonometric polynomial has real zeros in a period and is converted to a degree- algebraic polynomial. That normalization is recorded separately rather than identified with the one-sided display.