Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Alain Plagne, Recent progress on finite Bh[g]B_h[g] sets, author's manuscript (no venue or year printed), Section 4 (pp. 13-15), the problems on p. 14, as identified on the source card. The file prints no page numbers; pages are counted from its first page.

Statement

Setting. For h≥2h\ge2, g≥1g\ge1, Fh,g(N)F_{h,g}(N) is the largest size of a subset of {1,…,N}\{1,\ldots,N\} in which every integer has at most gg representations a1+⋯+aha_1+\cdots+a_h with a1≤⋯≤aha_1\le\cdots\le a_h (p. 1, formula (1)).

Problem 6 (p. 14), called by the paper the main unsolved question: does

ch,g=lim⁡N→+∞Fh,g(N)N1/h(19)c_{h,g}=\lim_{N\to+\infty}\frac{F_{h,g}(N)}{N^{1/h}}\qquad(19)

exist? The introduction (p. 3) already notes that it is not known whether Fh,g(N)N−1/hF_{h,g}(N)N^{-1/h} converges.

Problem 7 (p. 14) asks to compute ch,gc_{h,g} explicitly, or, if the limit does not exist, optimal upper and lower bounds. Problem 8 (p. 14) asks to compute c3,1c_{3,1} and c2,2c_{2,2} explicitly. After Problem 8 the paper recalls that in its reference [15] (Habsieger and Plagne) the authors conjectured c2,2=2c_{2,2}=2.

The paper calls the case g=1g=1, h=2h=2 solved, and the only solved case (p. 9): c2,1=1c_{2,1}=1, from formula (2), F2,1(N)∼NF_{2,1}(N)\sim\sqrt N (p. 2). The table on p. 13 gives the best known lower and upper bounds for Fh,g(N)N−1/hF_{h,g}(N)N^{-1/h} for 2≤h≤42\le h\le4 and 1≤g≤61\le g\le6; for (h,g)=(2,2)(h,g)=(2,2) it gives 1.51181.5118 and 2.29132.2913.

Read depth. Claims checked: Problems 6, 7 and 8, the attribution of the conjecture c2,2=2c_{2,2}=2 and the table row were read on pp. 3, 9 and 13-14. These are open problems; there is no proof to check.

Proof pointer

None: open problems.

Dependencies

None.

Bears on

  • Problem 863: its hypothesis ∣A∣∼crN1/2\lvert A\rvert\sim c_rN^{1/2} for maximal B2[r]B_2[r] sets in {1,…,N}\{1,\ldots,N\} is the existence of c2,rc_{2,r} in the paper's notation, which Problem 6 asks about. The paper proves nothing on it and does not discuss difference representations.
  • Problem 241: see Problem 9, which asks about c3,1c_{3,1} directly.