Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Lemma 2, p. 357, of Yong-Gao Chen, On integers of the form k2n+1k2^n+1, Proceedings of the American Mathematical Society 129(2), 355--361 (electronically published 28 August 2000), https://doi.org/10.1090/s0002-9939-00-05916-5, the edition named on the source card. A weak form with an ineffective constant is proved in Section 4, part (II), p. 360.

Read depth. Claims checked: the statement was read clause by clause on the printed page; the proof (p. 357) and the weak form (p. 360) were read for structure only. Nothing here is independently reviewed.

Statement

Lemma 2 (p. 357). "Let p1,⋯ ,ptp_1,\cdots,p_t be distinct odd primes and x≥3x\geq3. Then the number of positive odd integers M≤xM\leq x such that there exist a positive integer nn and distinct primes q1,⋯ ,qr∈{p1,⋯ ,pt}q_1,\cdots,q_r\in\{p_1,\cdots,p_t\} with

M2n+1=q1β1⋯qrβr,βi≥1,i=1,⋯ ,r,M2^n+1=q_1^{\beta_1}\cdots q_r^{\beta_r},\quad \beta_i\geq1,\quad i=1,\cdots,r,

is less than c1(log⁡log⁡x)(log⁡x)rc_1(\log\log x)(\log x)^r, where c1c_1 depends only on rr and p1,⋯ ,ptp_1,\cdots,p_t."

The constant is effective (p. 355).

Weak form (Section 4 (II), p. 360). For distinct primes q1,…,qrq_1,\ldots,q_r and 1≤M≤x1\le M\le x with M2n+1=q1β1⋯qrβrM2^n+1=q_1^{\beta_1}\cdots q_r^{\beta_r}, n≥1n\ge1, βi≥0\beta_i\ge0: those with n<log⁡xn<\log x number fewer than c(6)(log⁡x)r+1c^{(6)}(\log x)^{r+1}, and those with n≥log⁡xn\ge\log x satisfy M≤c(8)M\le c^{(8)}, where every c(i)c^{(i)} depends only on q1,…,qrq_1,\ldots,q_r. The bound c(8)c^{(8)} comes from the Mahler--Ridout theorem (Lemma 3, p. 359), and the paper calls the constants of Section 4 noneffective (p. 355). The paper says this weak form suffices for its purpose.

Proof pointer

Proof on p. 357. For fixed q1,…,qrq_1,\ldots,q_r, Yu's bound (Lemma 1, p. 357) applied to q1β1⋯qrβr−1=M2nq_1^{\beta_1}\cdots q_r^{\beta_r}-1=M2^n gives n≤clog⁡(12max⁡βi)n\le c\log(12\max\beta_i), equation (2); comparing sizes then gives max⁡βi<c2log⁡x\max\beta_i<c_2\log x, equation (3), so n≤c3log⁡log⁡xn\le c_3\log\log x, and counting the choices of nn and the βi\beta_i gives the bound, summed over the (tr)\binom{t}{r} choices of primes. The weak form replaces Lemma 1 by the Mahler--Ridout theorem (Lemma 3, p. 359).

Dependencies

Lemma 1 (p. 357), a special case of the corollary of Theorem 1 of K. Yu, Linear forms in pp-adic logarithms, III, Compositio Math. 91 (1994); for the weak form, Lemma 3 (p. 359), from Mahler (1957) and Ridout (1957).

Bears on

  • Problem 1113: the paper does not mention the problem. The lemma counts coefficients M≤xM\le x relative to a prime set fixed in advance; it says nothing about the covering sets of any single coefficient, so it neither produces a Sierpiński number without a finite covering set nor rules one out.