Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. The Frankl–Rosenberg theorem quoted on published p. 3; the cited original is A finite set intersection theorem, European Journal of Combinatorics 2 (1981), 127–129. The following finite elementary proof is supplied by the compilation. It covers exactly the positive-uniformity case needed for lemma_3_1.

Statement. Let a>0a>0, m≥2m\ge2 be integers, and let F\mathcal F be a finite family of aa-element subsets of a finite set. Suppose ∣F∩G∣≡b(modm)|F\cap G|\equiv b\pmod m for distinct members and a≢b(modm)a\not\equiv b\pmod m. Then their incidence vectors are linearly independent over Q\mathbb Q.

Proof. Suppose a rational dependence exists. Clear denominators and divide out the greatest common divisor to obtain integers λF\lambda_F, not all zero, with greatest common divisor one and ∑FλF1F=0\sum_F\lambda_F\mathbf1_F=0. Taking inner product with the all-ones vector gives a∑FλF=0a\sum_F\lambda_F=0, hence ∑FλF=0\sum_F\lambda_F=0. Taking inner product with 1G\mathbf1_G and reducing modulo mm gives

0≡aλG+b∑F≠GλF=(a−b)λG(modm).0\equiv a\lambda_G+b\sum_{F\ne G}\lambda_F =(a-b)\lambda_G\pmod m.

Because m∤a−bm\nmid a-b, some prime pp dividing mm satisfies vp(m)>vp(a−b)v_p(m)>v_p(a-b). The divisibility m∣(a−b)λGm\mid(a-b)\lambda_G then implies p∣λGp\mid\lambda_G for every GG. This contradicts the primitive choice of the coefficients. Therefore no dependence exists.

Range. Positivity of aa is explicit because the all-ones argument uses it. In Lemma 3.1, a=2n−4>0a=2n-4>0 and m=n−6≥5m=n-6\ge5. The original external paper is not independently reviewed, and no statement about zero-uniform families is needed.

Bears on. #174.