Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Theorem 1, p. 3, of P. Erdős, S. W. Graham, A. Ivić and C. Pomerance, On the number of divisors of n!, Analytic Number Theory (Progress in Mathematics), Birkhäuser Boston (1996), 337--355, doi:10.1007/978-1-4612-4086-0_19, read in the authors' manuscript named on the source card; pages here are that manuscript's printed pages 1--16, and the published pagination was not compared.

Statement

Notation (pp. 1--3). d(m)d(m) is the number of positive divisors of mm, and [x][x] is the integer part of xx. The constants are defined by display (3) on p. 3:

ck=∫1∞log⁡([t]+1)t2log⁡kt dt(k≥0).c_k=\int_1^\infty\frac{\log([t]+1)}{t^2}\log^k t\,dt\qquad(k\ge0).

Theorem 1 (p. 3). "For any fixed integer K≥0K\ge0 and ckc_k given by (3) we have

d(n!)=exp⁡{nlog⁡n∑k=0Kcklog⁡kn+O(nlog⁡K+2n)}."d(n!)=\exp\Bigl\{\frac{n}{\log n}\sum_{k=0}^{K}\frac{c_k}{\log^k n}+O\Bigl(\frac{n}{\log^{K+2}n}\Bigr)\Bigr\}."

In particular (p. 3), c0=∑k≥2log⁡kk(k−1)≈1.25775c_0=\sum_{k\ge2}\frac{\log k}{k(k-1)}\approx1.25775, so log⁡d(n!)∼c0 n/log⁡n\log d(n!)\sim c_0\,n/\log n. With m=n!m=n! and Stirling's formula the paper restates the case K=0K=0 on p. 3 as

log⁡d(m)=c0log⁡m(log⁡log⁡m)2(1+O(log⁡log⁡log⁡mlog⁡log⁡m)),\log d(m)=\frac{c_0\log m}{(\log\log m)^2}\Bigl(1+O\Bigl(\frac{\log\log\log m}{\log\log m}\Bigr)\Bigr),

to be compared with Wigert's bound log⁡d(m)≤log⁡2 log⁡m/log⁡log⁡m+O(log⁡m/(log⁡log⁡m)2)\log d(m)\le\log2\,\log m/\log\log m+O(\log m/(\log\log m)^2) for all mm (display (1), p. 1).

Read depth. Claims checked: the statement, display (3) and the value of c0c_0 were read clause by clause on the page images on 2026-10-08; the proof on pp. 2--3 was read for structure only. Nothing here is independently reviewed.

Proof sketch

Pp. 2--3. Write n!=∏p≤npwp(n)n!=\prod_{p\le n}p^{w_p(n)} with wp(n)=∑j≥1[n/pj]w_p(n)=\sum_{j\ge1}[n/p^j], so log⁡d(n!)=∑p≤nlog⁡(wp(n)+1)\log d(n!)=\sum_{p\le n}\log(w_p(n)+1). The primes p≤n3/4p\le n^{3/4} contribute O(n3/4)O(n^{3/4}), since wp(n)<n/(p−1)w_p(n)<n/(p-1). For p>n3/4p>n^{3/4} one has wp(n)=[n/p]w_p(n)=[n/p], and the prime number theorem with error O(xe−log⁡x)O(xe^{-\sqrt{\log x}}) turns the sum into ∫n3/4nlog⁡([n/x]+1) dx/log⁡x\int_{n^{3/4}}^{n}\log([n/x]+1)\,dx/\log x plus O(ne−12log⁡n)O(ne^{-\frac12\sqrt{\log n}}). Substituting x=n/tx=n/t and expanding 1/log⁡(n/t)1/\log(n/t) in powers of log⁡t/log⁡n\log t/\log n gives the stated expansion.

Dependencies

The prime number theorem with the classical error term (the paper cites Davenport and Ivić's book); no other result of the paper.

Bears on

  • Problem 420: the paper remarks on p. 5 that Theorem 1 immediately gives that the average order of K(n)K(n), the least KK with d((n+K)!)≥2d(n!)d((n+K)!)\ge2d(n!), is of the order of log⁡n\log n. This places the problem's shift log⁡n\log n at the typical scale for doubling; it does not bear on any of the problem's questions directly.