Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.
Updated
Statement
The two maps (p. 1). The Collatz function is for and for . The function is for and for . The survey records the relation for odd and for even , so that iterating omits some of the steps of iterating ; it credits the observation that is the more convenient map for analysis to Terras (its [88], [89]) and Everett (its [27]), independently.
Conjecture (p. 1, unnumbered), quoted: "Starting from any positive integer , iterations of the function will eventually reach the number 1. Thereafter iterations will cycle, taking successive values ."
Reformulations stated in the survey. Backwards (p. 4): let be the smallest set of integers that contains and is closed under the maps and , the second applied only to inputs for which is an integer; the conjecture then says that is the set of all positive integers. Through powers of (p. 13): the conjecture can be restated as saying that from every positive integer some iterate of the Collatz function, or of the function, is a power of .
Source. J. C. Lagarias, The problem: an overview, in The Ultimate Challenge: The Problem (AMS, 2010), 3--29; the arXiv:2111.02635v1 copy, p. 1 (the maps and the conjecture), p. 4 (the set ) and p. 13 (the power-of-2 form), read on the page images. The edition read is identified on the source card.
Read depth. Claims checked: the definitions, the conjecture and the two reformulations were read clause by clause on the page images. The conjecture is open; nothing here is a proof, and nothing here is independently reviewed.
Proof pointer
None: the statement is a conjecture. The equivalences with the backward and power-of-2 forms are asserted in the survey without proof. The backward form rests on the observation that the inverse images of under are and, when , the odd integer ; so the two maps generate from exactly the positive integers whose -orbit contains (a remark of this page, not of the survey).
Dependencies
None.
Bears on
- Problem 1135: the problem's map is the survey's , and its question, whether every has some with , is the survey's Conjecture stated for in place of . The survey poses the conjecture for ; by the relation ( odd), ( even) the -orbit of is the -orbit with some terms left out, and the two orbits reach together, as the problem page's map remark explains. The survey states the conjecture and proves nothing about it.