Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Statement

Corollaire (printed pp. 1049--1050). Let n≥1n\ge1 and let 2n+12n+1 distinct points z0,…,z2nz_0,\ldots,z_{2n} be given on the unit circle. Among the polynomials P2n(z)P_{2n}(z) of degree 2n2n whose modulus is at most 11 at these points, some reach modulus (2π−o(1))log⁡n(\frac2\pi-o(1))\log n on the circle as n→∞n\to\infty, whatever the points.

The printed hypothesis reads "atteint la valeur 1" at the points; the proof on p. 1050 takes the polynomial that realizes the largest modulus at a point zz, and the value it displays is that largest modulus under the bound ∣P2n(zk)∣≤1|P_{2n}(z_k)|\le1 at z0,…,z2nz_0,\ldots,z_{2n}. The statement above is given in that reading. With A2n+1(z)=(z−z0)⋯(z−z2n)A_{2n+1}(z)=(z-z_0)\cdots(z-z_{2n}) that largest modulus is

∣A2n+1(z)∣∑k=02n1∣z−zk∣ ∣A2n+1′(zk)∣,|A_{2n+1}(z)|\sum_{k=0}^{2n}\frac1{|z-z_k|\,|A_{2n+1}'(z_k)|},

and for z=eiφz=e^{i\varphi}, zk=eiθkz_k=e^{i\theta_k} the paper identifies it with the trigonometric Lebesgue function (37 bis) of the points θk\theta_k, so the corollary follows from the Théorème.

Source. Serge Bernstein, Sur la limitation des valeurs d'un polynôme Pn(x)P_n(x) de degré nn sur tout un segment par ses valeurs en (n+1)(n+1) points du segment, Bull. Acad. Sci. URSS, Classe des sciences mathématiques et naturelles, VII série (1931), no. 8, 1025--1050; the Corollaire and its proof on printed pp. 1049--1050 (PDF pp. 25--26). The paper writes "la circonférence cc"; its proof takes zk=eiθkz_k=e^{i\theta_k}. The copy read is identified on the source card.

Read depth. Claims checked: the statement and its reduction to (37 bis) were read on the page images. The reduction is an identity between moduli (∣eiφ−eiθ∣=2∣sin⁡φ−θ2∣|e^{i\varphi}-e^{i\theta}|=2|\sin\frac{\varphi-\theta}2|); the Théorème it rests on is claims-checked only.

Proof pointer

Page 1050: the paper states that the extremal value at zz is the displayed sum (the interpolation formula with node values of modulus one chosen to align every term, a step it does not write out); writing the factors through ∣eiφ−eiθ∣|e^{i\varphi}-e^{i\theta}| turns it into (37 bis), and the Théorème applies.

Dependencies

The Théorème of p. 1041, with its interfaces listed there.

Bears on

  • Problem 1129, its adjacent unit-circle variant (Erdős's question on nodes on the circle, recorded on that page): for an odd number 2n+12n+1 of nodes the corollary gives the asymptotic lower bound (2π−o(1))log⁡n(\frac2\pi-o(1))\log n for the maximum of the circle Lebesgue function. It says nothing about which nodes minimize, and the variant carries no claim page there.