Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Theorem 1a, printed p. 150 (published PDF).

Statement. In the notation of the maximum-union formula, there are partial transversals T1,…,TkT_1,\ldots,T_k with ∣Tt∣=nt|T_t|=n_t and ⋃tTt=E\bigcup_tT_t=E if and only if

nt≤ρ(E)(1≤t≤k),∣A∣≤∑j=1σ(A)nj∗=∑tmin⁡(nt,σ(A))(A⊆E).(1)n_t\le\rho(E)\quad(1\le t\le k),\qquad |A|\le\sum_{j=1}^{\sigma(A)}n_j^* =\sum_t\min(n_t,\sigma(A)) \quad(A\subseteq E). \tag{1}

In this criterion ρ(A)\rho(A) may replace σ(A)\sigma(A). The sets in the cover need not be disjoint.

Proof. A covering partial transversal has size at most ρ(E)\rho(E). For each AA, its intersection with TtT_t has at most ntn_t elements and uses at most σ(A)\sigma(A) distinct family indices. Therefore

∣A∣≤∑t∣A∩Tt∣≤∑tmin⁡(nt,σ(A)).|A|\le\sum_t|A\cap T_t| \le\sum_t\min(n_t,\sigma(A)).

This proves necessity. The same argument with the rank bound on A∩TtA\cap T_t also proves necessity of the rank-form criterion.

Conversely, (1) says that every objective in the maximum-union formula is at least ∣E∣|E|. That maximum cannot exceed ∣E∣|E|, so there is a disjoint packing of partial transversals StS_t of sizes at most ntn_t whose union is EE.

Partial transversals are independent in the transversal matroid. Extend each StS_t, separately, to an independent set TtT_t of size ntn_t, using nt≤ρ(E)n_t\le\rho(E) and finite basis extension. The union remains EE, though these extensions may overlap. This gives the required cover. The rank version follows by the same reasoning using the rank minimum formula. □\square