Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Source. Published p. 284, Theorem 10.5 (PDF).

Statement. If ∣A△B∣=d|A\mathbin\triangle B|=d for all cross pairs from A,B⊆2[n]\mathcal A,\mathcal B\subseteq2^{[n]}, then ∣A∣∣B∣≤2n|\mathcal A||\mathcal B|\le2^n. If n≠2dn\ne2d, the upper bound improves to 2n−12^{n-1}.

Proof. Assume both families nonempty and map a set to its vector of ±1\pm1 coordinates, denoting the two point families by A′,B′A',B'. All these vectors have squared norm nn, and every cross inner product is the same number c=n−2dc=n-2d. Write their affine hulls as u0+Vu_0+V and w0+Ww_0+W. Subtracting the constant inner-product identity in either variable shows that every point of A′A' is orthogonal to WW, and every point of B′B' is orthogonal to VV. Hence V⊥WV\perp W and dim⁡V+dim⁡W≤n\dim V+\dim W\le n. Proposition 10.4 gives

∣A∣∣B∣≤2dim⁡V+dim⁡W≤2n.|\mathcal A||\mathcal B|\le2^{\dim V+\dim W}\le2^n.

If the dimensions sum to at most n−1n-1, this already gives the improved bound. Otherwise W⊥=VW^\perp=V and V⊥=WV^\perp=W. The preceding pointwise orthogonality gives u0∈Vu_0\in V and w0∈Ww_0\in W, so both affine hulls pass through the origin and all cross inner products are zero. Thus c=n−2d=0c=n-2d=0. This proves the strict improvement whenever n≠2dn\ne2d.

For sharpness at n=2dn=2d, partition the ground set into dd two-element blocks. Let A\mathcal A choose one point in each block, and let B\mathcal B choose either both points or neither in each block. Every block contributes one to every cross symmetric difference. Both families have size 2d2^d, so their product is 2n2^n. □\square

Source precision. Orthogonality first concerns the direction spaces of the affine hulls; the last argument is what forces the hulls through the origin in the full-dimension case. The source also prints the origin's distance to a ±1\pm1 vector as 2n2\sqrt n; that distance is n\sqrt n. The proof above uses the exact common squared norm nn.

Dependencies. proposition_10_4.