Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Welsh's same-paper deductions use the following earlier results. Their use is explicit on printed pp. 1324–1329 (published PDF).

Finite independent representatives

The external theorem attributed to R. Rado, A theorem on independence relations, Quarterly Journal of Mathematics 13 (1942), 83–89, is:

Let (S,M)(S,M) be a finite matroid with rank function rr, and let (Cℓ)ℓ∈L(C_\ell)_{\ell\in L} be a finite indexed family of subsets of SS. There is an injective assignment cℓ∈Cℓc_\ell\in C_\ell whose range is independent in MM if and only if

r(⋃ℓ∈KCℓ)≥∣K∣(K⊆L).r\left(\bigcup_{\ell\in K}C_\ell\right)\ge |K| \qquad(K\subseteq L).

For L=∅L=\varnothing, the empty assignment is the conclusion. This exact finite interface is also recorded in the Rado (1949) external-input page. The 1942 primary paper and its proof have not been acquired or reconstructed in either source unit. Every Welsh result that uses this theorem is therefore a complete relative proof, not a new proof of Rado's theorem.

Transversal and Hall inputs

The statement that partial transversals of a finite indexed family form a matroid has a complete alternating-path proof in Edmonds–Fulkerson's transversal-matroid theorem. Welsh attributes this result independently to Mirsky–Perfect and Edmonds–Fulkerson.

The exact ordinary union criterion used for replicated families is Hall's theorem. The labeled-copy form for a uniform multiplicity bound is also expanded in the Hall replication argument.

Finite independent-set augmentation and extension to a base are proved in elementary finite matroid facts. Together with the transversal-matroid theorem, they justify the local partial-to-full transversal augmentation.

Perfect and common-transversal comparisons

The source states H. Perfect's rank-defect corollary without proof. A complete deduction from the exact finite Rado input is supplied on the local Perfect-corollary page. This does not compile Perfect's unpublished 1967 seminar report.

Welsh cites Ford and Fulkerson's 1962 book for a common-transversal result. The related canonical common-SDR theorem proves the pi=qi=1p_i=q_i=1 comparison from their 1958 paper. It is not presented as an inspection of the separately cited book.

All remaining partition-matroid, copied-ground-set, rank, and defect calculations used by this unit are proved on the local result pages.