Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Claim. Corollary 1 of Product of integers in an interval, modulo squares (Electron. J. Combin. 8 (2001), #R5, p. 4) proves two bounds for the tnt_n of Problem 841. If P(n)>2n+1P(n)>\sqrt{2n}+1, where P(n)P(n) is the largest prime factor of nn, then tn=P(n)t_n=P(n). Otherwise tn≤3n/2+1t_n\le3\sqrt{n/2}+1. Write n=apn=ap with p=P(n)p=P(n). In the first case, the bound tn≤pt_n\le p comes from five explicit integers in (n,n+p](n,n+p], the largest being n+pn+p, whose product with nn is a square. The second case follows from the paper's Theorem 2. The site credits the result to Selfridge.

Covers. The exact value of tnt_n for every nn with P(n)>2n+1P(n)>\sqrt{2n}+1, and tn≪nt_n\ll\sqrt n for every other nn. It does not give the distribution of tnt_n.

The companion lower bound tn≥p(n)t_n\ge p(n) holds when p(n)p(n) is the largest prime dividing nn to an odd power, as the paper's preceding paragraph defines it. It fails for the largest prime divisor, which is how the corollary names p(n)p(n): t242=8<11t_{242}=8<11.

Acceptance. The paper appeared in the Electronic Journal of Combinatorics, a refereed journal, which is the refereed evidence.

Formalization. The OpenAI Codex development linked on the Bui-Pratt-Zaharescu page states that it proves the exact large-prime estimate of Granville and Selfridge. Its final theorem has tn=P(n)t_n=P(n) for P(n)>2n+1P(n)>\sqrt{2n}+1 and the weaker tn≤40nt_n\le40\sqrt n otherwise. This corpus has not built it, so it is not formalized evidence.