Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Green and Tao determine f(n)f(n) exactly for all sufficiently large nn: nn points in the real plane, not all on one line, determine at least n/2n/2 ordinary lines, lines through exactly two of the points (Theorem 1.2, the Dirac-Motzkin conjecture), and more precisely at least f(n)f(n) of them, where f(2m)=mf(2m)=m, f(4m+1)=3mf(4m+1)=3m and f(4m−1)=3m−3f(4m-1)=3m-3, so f(n)=3⌊n/4⌋f(n)=3\lfloor n/4\rfloor for odd nn (Theorem 2.2). Every one of these values is attained: n/2n/2 equally spaced points on a circle together with the n/2n/2 points at infinity in the directions of the lines joining them (the sides and diagonals of the regular polygon) span exactly n/2n/2 ordinary lines. When n/2n/2 is even, adding the center gives n+1n+1 points with 3n/43n/4 ordinary lines, and removing a point at infinity that lies on the tangents at two opposite circle points gives n−1n-1 points with 3n/4−33n/4-3; when n/2n/2 is odd, removing any one point at infinity gives n−1n-1 points with 3(n−2)/43(n-2)/4 (Proposition 2.1, the Böröczky examples); Theorem 2.2 adds that, up to a projective transformation, these are the only sets attaining f(n)f(n). Both theorems follow from a structure theorem (Theorems 1.4 and 1.5): a set with at most KnKn ordinary lines has all but O(K)O(K) of its points on a cubic curve, for nn large in terms of KK. The source card [[../library/discrete_geometry/green_2013_sets_defining_few_ordinary_lines/_index|records Theorems 1.2 and 2.2, Proposition 2.1 and the structure theorems]].

This settles the second question of Problem 210, how fast f(n)f(n) grows: linearly, with f(n)=n/2f(n)=n/2 for even nn and f(n)=3⌊n/4⌋f(n)=3\lfloor n/4\rfloor for odd nn once nn is large, after the bounds 3n/73n/7 of Kelly and Moser and 6n/136n/13 of Csima and Sawyer, and Motzkin's proof that f(n)→∞f(n)\to\infty. The threshold n0n_0 is not made explicit, and the exact value of f(n)f(n) for small nn is not what the question asks.

The result is refereed: Ben Green and Terence Tao, On sets defining few ordinary lines, Discrete Comput. Geom. 50 (2013), no. 2, 409-468; the preprint is arXiv:1208.4714, first posted 2012-08-23. The site's curator, T. F. Bloom, marks the problem proved and credits this paper with the bound n/2n/2 for large nn and with the odd case.