Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Claim. Alper Ferudun, arXiv:2606.28041v1, submitted 26 June 2026 (the claim's date), asserts in its Theorem 1.1 that for every integer 1≤n≤401\le n\le40 the largest number of edge deletions a triangle-free graph on 5n5n vertices needs to become bipartite is exactly n2n^2. The upper bound answers the question of Problem 23 yes for those nn, and the balanced blow-up of C5C_5 (five stable sets of nn vertices, complete bipartite graphs between cyclically consecutive sets) needs n2n^2 deletions, so the value is exact. Ferudun also stated the values a(5k)=k2a(5k)=k^2 for 1≤k≤401\le k\le40 in a comment on OEIS A389646 dated 29 June 2026, citing the preprint. The certificates and the full proof are not independently reviewed. The introduction also contains prose that does not agree with the theorem's range (it speaks of eleven multiples of five and of n≥12n\ge12), recorded as an unresolved textual inconsistency.

Covers. The question for graphs on 5n5n vertices with 1≤n≤401\le n\le40. Nothing for n>40n>40: the problem asks about every nn, and neither a proof for all nn nor a counterexample follows. The claim combines the two edge-density tails of Balogh, Clemen and Lidický's Theorem 2(b),(c) with Ferudun's own certificate for the middle band: Ferudun's Theorem 4.1 cites their theorem, at most N2/25N^2/25 deletions for edge density at most 0.24860.2486 or at least 0.31970.3197 once NN is sufficiently large, and the paper's Corollary 4.2 carries it to each N≤200N\le200 by blowing up, through the identity β(G[t])=t2β(G)\beta(G[t])=t^2\beta(G) for the deletion number of the tt-fold blow-up; an order-10 certificate then covers the densities between the two thresholds. Only their general bound of N2/23.5N^2/23.5 deletions, that is (50/47)n2(50/47)n^2, is cited and not used.

Depends on. Theorem 2(b),(c) of Balogh, Clemen and Lidický, for the two edge-density tails; nothing else in this wiki.

Standing. Claimed: a preprint with no journal record and no independent review found in the search that the problem page records; the site's proof-claim tab carried no entry for this problem on 2026-10-06. The claim is partial, so the problem's standing is unchanged by it.