Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


Claim. Let f(n,k)f(n,k) be the least number such that in every two-coloring of the edges of KnK_n one can find vertex-disjoint monochromatic copies of KkK_k, of either color, leaving at most f(n,k)f(n,k) vertices uncovered. Theorem 6 of Burr, Erdős and Spencer (Trans. Amer. Math. Soc. 209 (1975), p. 94) states that for fixed kk and all sufficiently large nn

f(n,k)=r(k,k−1)−1+rem(n−r(k,k−1)+1, k),f(n,k)=r(k,k-1)-1+\mathrm{rem}(n-r(k,k-1)+1,\,k),

where r(k,k−1)r(k,k-1) is the off-diagonal Ramsey number and rem(a,b)\mathrm{rem}(a,b) the remainder of aa on division by bb. So f(n,k)f(n,k) is eventually periodic in nn with period kk, between r(k,k−1)−1r(k,k-1)-1 and r(k,k−1)+k−2r(k,k-1)+k-2. The lower bound is a coloring with a set BB of r(k,k−1)−1r(k,k-1)-1 vertices colored with no red KkK_k and no blue Kk−1K_{k-1}, blue edges from BB to the rest and red edges inside the rest, so that no vertex of BB lies in a monochromatic KkK_k; the upper bound finds a large monochromatic clique by Ramsey's theorem, for n≥r(u,u)n\ge r(u,u) with u=(k−1)(r(k,k)−r(k,k−1))+(k−1)(k−2)+1u=(k-1)(r(k,k)-r(k,k-1))+(k-1)(k-2)+1, and uses it to complete leftover blue Kk−1K_{k-1}'s to monochromatic KkK_k's. This is the estimate Problem 1015 asks for, read, as the site's commentary reads it, with nn large in terms of t=kt=k: the site's f(t)f(t) is the eventual value of f(n,t)f(n,t), and the exact growth of ff is that of r(k,k−1)r(k,k-1).

Scope. Full, in the sense of the site's SOLVED label, which attaches to this determination. The two closing questions, whether f(t)1/t→1f(t)^{1/t}\to1 and whether f(t)≪tf(t)\ll t, are not stated in the paper; both have answer no because r(k,k−1)≥R(k−1)r(k,k-1)\ge R(k-1) grows exponentially by Erdős's 1947 bound, a one-line consequence the problem page writes out and names as its own, which warrants nothing here. The site's printed formula, f(t)=R(t,t−1)+x(t,n)f(t)=R(t,t-1)+x(t,n) with the same remainder xx, exceeds the paper's by 11; the problem page records the discrepancy against Moon's values for k=3k=3 and does not repair it.

Depends on. Nothing in this wiki; the result is the paper's own theorem over Ramsey's theorem.

Acceptance. Reviewed: the site's curator, T. F. Bloom, labels the problem SOLVED and in its commentary credits Burr, Erdős and Spencer with the determination of ff for nn large in terms of tt; the curator is independent of the authors. Refereed: the paper appeared in Transactions of the American Mathematical Society 209 (1975), 87--99, received 14 January 1974 (Crossref record; the record gives the year only, so the page's month and day are placeholders). The site's discussion thread and proof-claim tab are empty. OpenAlex lists 88 citing works (2026-09-18), whose titles record no dispute.

Read depth. The text read is the Rényi archive's scan, which the library does not hold: the opening of Section 5, the trivial bound, Theorem 6 and the lower-bound coloring were checked clause by clause and the upper-bound argument read for structure. Nothing here is independent review.