Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.
Updated
Claim. Theorem 2 (p. 2) is printed as "For every , and every integer , there exists an integer such that for every prime , and every integer , there exist integers such that , and " (Integers 4 (2004), #A20, p. 2, as in arXiv v2; arXiv v1 and the copy on the author's papers page print ). With this is the question of Problem 1180 for , with and repetition allowed, read with at most summands. As printed, with exactly summands, the statement holds only for large : for a prime with , and for at every , the only admissible is , and a sum of exactly of them is the single residue . The proof covers the finitely many small primes by enlarging , which works when bounds the number of summands, and the one-line completion of Shparlinski's and Glibichuk's pages (a residue is the sum of copies of ) gives them; Glibichuk's introduction restates the theorem for sufficiently large . For the set contains the set for , so serves (the monotonicity remark of the problem page). The resulting is not explicit. The theorem is compiled on the result page theorem_2; the digest is on the card croot_2004_sums_reciprocal_powers_modulo_prime.
Argument, in outline. The Bourgain--Katz--Tao sum-product estimate is applied to the sums of inverse th powers of small primes, and an exponential-sum lemma then writes every residue as with the in a set of sums of inverse th powers, which the paper counts as at most terms (pp. 2--5). The outline records the structure only; no step is checked. The paper's introduction states the Erdős--Graham question in the monograph's form and credits its first affirmative answer to Shparlinski, through Karatsuba's result in the simplified form of Friedlander and Iwaniec; that answer is on Shparlinski's page.
Acceptance. Refereed: Ernie Croot, Sums of the form
modulo a prime, Integers 4 (2004), Paper A20, per the
journal's volume contents and the Zenodo deposit of the paper; the journal's
text, deposited at Zenodo under CC-BY-4.0, agrees with arXiv:math/0403360v2 (21
October 2004); arXiv v1 and the copy on the author's papers page differ from it
in the introduction and Theorem 2. The page is named by the first arXiv posting,
v1 of 22 March 2004, under the title "Reciprocal power sums modulo a prime". Not
reviewed: the site's curator names Croot, in the problem's commentary, only for
the earlier bound of summands from his 1999 paper, not for
this theorem, so no reviewed evidence is listed. Nothing here is independently
reviewed by this project.
Depends on. Nothing on the wiki; the theorem is proved in the refereed paper linked above.