Wiki
Wiki

Research notes on every problem, and a library of the papers behind them. Built from the open erdos repository.

Updated


In the corrected range of lemma_2, for every U⊆[n]U\subseteq[n],

∣{A⊆U:s(A)≤x}∣≥2Hn(x)−(n−∣U∣)−Ox0,δ(cn).|\{A\subseteq U:s(A)\le x\}| \ge 2^{\mathcal H_n(x)-(n-|U|)-O_{x_0,\delta}(\sqrt{cn})}.

Since c≤C(x0)c\le C(x_0), this implies the source-strength error Ox0,δ(n/c)O_{x_0,\delta}(\sqrt{n/c}). This is an explicitly compilation-supplied alternative, using the source's product law and moment estimates; it is not the printed conditional-entropy proof. The latter is reconstructed at conditional_entropy.

Bears on. Problem 297.

Proof

Put q=cnq=cn and L=∑m=1nlog⁡(1+e−q/m)L=\sum_{m=1}^n\log(1+e^{-q/m}). The product law assigns to a subset A⊆[n]A\subseteq[n] the exact probability

Pr⁡(Y=A)=exp⁡(−L−qs(A)),Hn(x)log⁡2=L+qx.(1)\Pr(Y=A)=\exp(-L-qs(A)),\qquad \mathcal H_n(x)\log2=L+qx. \tag{1}

The second identity follows by expanding the entropy of each Bernoulli variable and using EZ=x\mathbb EZ=x. Let σ2=Var⁡Z=Θ(q−1)\sigma^2=\operatorname{Var}Z=\Theta(q^{-1}). Berry–Esseen gives a fixed positive probability, say at least a0>0a_0>0, to x−σ<Z≤xx-\sigma<Z\le x for large qq: subtract the two distribution functions at normalized values 0 and −1-1. The error is O(q−1/2)O(q^{-1/2}) and Φ(0)−Φ(−1)>0\Phi(0)-\Phi(-1)>0.

Each atom in this window has, by (1), probability at most exp⁡(−Hn(x)log⁡2+qσ)\exp(-\mathcal H_n(x)\log2+q\sigma). There must therefore be at least a0exp⁡(Hn(x)log⁡2−qσ)a_0\exp(\mathcal H_n(x)\log2-q\sigma) such atoms. Since qσ=O(q)q\sigma=O(\sqrt q), this proves the bound for U=[n]U=[n]. Intersect each set with UU. Positivity of the reciprocal weights preserves the inequality s(A∩U)≤xs(A\cap U)\le x, and each image has at most 2n−∣U∣2^{n-|U|} preimages. This gives the stated bound.